Skip to main content

From Lecture Hall to Policy Desk: A Science-for-Policy Session for Law Students

Key features in a nutshell

  • This format introduces law students and early-career legal researchers to academic policy engagement through two short scenario-based exercises embedded in a regular spring school programme
  • The first exercise trains participants to quickly extract key messages from academic and policy publications under real-time pressure, role-playing as parliamentary staffers preparing a same-day briefing
  • The second exercise uses Roger Pielke Jr.’s ‘honest broker’ framework to help participants critically reflect on the different roles researchers can play when advising policymakers
  • Both exercises require minimal preparation from facilitators and participants alike making this an easy addition to existing curricula – legal or otherwise

 

How did the format work?

Step 1: Conceptualization and Curriculum Design

Together with colleagues from the Sant’Anna School of Advanced Studies in Pisa and Basel University, the authors organised the Spring School ‘Criminal Law and the Anthropocene: Cross-disciplinary Perspectives and Critical Approaches’ in Pisa in May 2026, for Master’s and doctoral students.

The Spring School comprised legal and interdisciplinary lectures, panel discussions, and writing workshops. The organisers deliberately sought to integrate a dedicated Science-for-Policy session for two key reasons:

  1. Lack of formal training: Although legal scholars frequently advise policymakers, they rarely receive formal training on how to communicate their expertise effectively or reflect on their role as science advisers.
  2. Careers in policymaking institutions: Many law graduates pursue careers in policymaking institutions. When drafting legislation on complex issues like climate change, they must seek expertise from natural scientists whose technical terminology and publication formats differ significantly from legal scholarship. These differences make it challenging for both sides to understand each other.

Since we had already collaborated with the ENGAGEgreen project at Goethe University, we knew the team was developing a Policy Engagement Toolkit, including teaching and learning materials. We approached the ENGAGEgreen team and presented our idea for a science-policy session; they provided descriptions of two exercises for us to use.

Step 2: Run the science-for-policy Session

The one-hour session was structured around two practical exercises followed by plenary discussions:

  • Exercise 1: Assessing publication acessibility (The eight-minute challenge)

Participants were assigned the roles of busy parliamentary staffers tasked with briefing an MP on salient policy issues (natural disasters and pesticide taxation). Working under extreme time pressure, participants had just eight minutes to scan four academic and policy-oriented publications to extract key messages and judge their readability.

  • Exercise 2: Reflecting advisory roles (The honest broker)

Participants analysed a scenario involving an interdisciplinary research team on nutrition asked by a mayor’s office for policy advice. Working in small groups, participants matched fictitious statements from team members with ideal-type advisory roles as conceptualised in Roger Pielke Jr.’s The Honest Broker (Pure Scientist, Science Arbiter, Issue Advocate, and Honest Broker).

Both exercises concluded with an interactive plenary discussion; twenty students and early career researchers participated in the session.

Step 3: Evaluation and participant feedback

Participant feedback was very positive. For many students and early-career researchers, working with concrete policy scenarios was a completely new experience. The session proved to be a highly effective, light-touch way to introduce academic policy engagement. While no formal evaluation results are available, the final discussion highlighted a productive controversy between the scientification of politics and the politicisation of science – an ambivalence we had deliberately addressed. Students engaged actively in this discussion, reflecting on the need to develop a self-understanding as researchers while recognising the limits, fallibility, and contingency of scientific knowledge in policy advice. The fact that this space for self-reflection emerged spontaneously in response to students’ contributions was positively received afterwards. The session can easily be integrated into standard university law curricula, or doctoral training.

 

Tasks and resources: Brief description of the tasks and resources needed by scientists, knowledge exchange officers/research managers and policymakers

Workshop facilitators

It took us approximately 3–4 hours to prepare, run, and evaluate the session. The teaching materials provided by the ENGAGEgreen project team were very helpful and easy to use.

Participating researchers and students

Participating doctoral researchers and students did not need to prepare in advance. They simply needed to bring a laptop to take part in the two exercises.

Policymakers

This was the first time we ran this session, and we deliberately kept it simple: we did not invite external policymakers since the spring school took place in Pisa, away from our usual Frankfurt-based networks. In hindsight, we do see clear added value in including policy professionals in future iterations, particularly junior policy professionals, who might be just as interested in sharing their own expertise needs with doctoral researchers and Master’s students as the students are in learning from them. For institutions replicating this format outside their home city, our advice would be to reach out to local or regional policy contacts at the host institution early on.

Sources and further reading

Pictures


Do you want to know more about the policy engagement toolkit?

Do you want to share your experience in policy engagement? Do you think about contributing to the policy engagement toolkit? Feel free to contact Tome Sandevski via science-policy@pvw.uni-frankfurt.de

 

Get Started, Keep Learning! A Facilitator’s Approach to Policy Engagement Training

Key features in a nutshell

  • Hands-on exercises beat slide decks: Participants gain a far deeper understanding of policymaking by analyzing real-world policy documents, organizational charts, and invitation pitches rather than consuming lectures passively
  • Teach competencies while considering capacities: Training builds the competencies needed for effective policy engagement, but capacities – time, funding, institutional access to policymakers, support structures – determine whether those competencies can actually be applied; there is no one-size-fits-all: effective policy engagement means matching formats and channels to participants’ resources and motivation.
  • “Get started, keep learning!” is the key message for the training: Participants should not wait to engage with policymakers until they have become policy experts themselves or mastered every possible format; by the end of the training, they need the confidence and skills to get started, knowing they will keep learning along the way.
  • Policymaker voices are essential: Having Members of Parliament or their staff, policy professionals from ministries, EU institutions, or international organizations talk about their tasks, routines, and experiences is invaluable; invite policymakers to join sessions whenever possible.

 

How does the format work?

Facilitating 33 workshops since 2019 – ranging from 60-minute crash courses to two-day intensive retreats – has been an ongoing process of practice, feedback, and refinement. Here are the core insights gained from continuously evolving these sessions.

 

From Slide Heavy to Hands-On (Practicing What We Preach)

In early workshops, a recurring piece of feedback was that I covered too many slides at too fast a pace. This was an eye-opener: while I was advising researchers to deliver concise key messages rather than overwhelming policymakers with information, my own slide decks were doing the exact opposite.

The Shift: I radically reduced the presentation slides in favor of active learning; today, participants work through various exercises (e.g., readability checks of policy briefs, audience mapping, crafting elevator pitches, analyzing organizational charts).

Pre-Workshop Preparation: Optional pre-workshop exercises (15–45 min) are offered to help participants get the maximum value out of the live session.

Result: Hands-on exercises are consistently rated highly since they help participants understand the importance of targeted communication and the constraints under which policymakers operate – and learning through doing tends to stick better than learning through listening.

Importance of capacities: In theory, researchers have many ways to engage with policymakers. In practice, capacities – time, funding, institutional access, support structures – determine which of these are realistic. A senior professor with a seat on an expert body, support by a dedicated secretariat, and institutional access has far more options than a doctoral researcher who is not yet known to policymakers and struggles to cover travel costs to a policy event in the capital.

The Shift: Rather than presenting a “one-size-fits-all” menu of engagement formats, the training actively addresses structural barriers. Facilitators must help participants identify time-efficient formats tailored to their specific career stage and available resources.

Empowering Early Action: I make clear that my workshops are not academic introductions to policymaking. Participants do not need to become policy experts nor master every detail of drafting policy briefs or organizing policy events.

The Shift: What they need is enough understanding to get started sooner rather than later. They leave with checklists covering what to address next, and with the confidence to begin engaging – knowing that further learning will come with practice.

Involving policymakers: Incorporating guests from ministries, the European Commission, international organizations, or parliaments (usually staffers) for a 1-to-2-hour concluding Q&A session has proven to be very effective.

The Shift: Participants consistently find it valuable to hear directly about policymakers’ constraints, routines, and expertise needs. The policymakers involved are typically approachable and encourage participants to reach out proactively. In in-person workshops, they are usually invited to lunch as well, which further supports informal exchange and networking.

 

Tasks and resources: Brief description of the tasks and resources needed by scientists, knowledge exchange officers/research managers and policymakers

Workshop facilitators

While individual workshops run between 60 minutes and two days, developing their structure and content has taken several months in total over the years. After each session, I review participant feedback and update the relevant material, including repeated revisions to the slide decks. Cutting slides was painful but proved essential.

Researchers and research managers as participants in workshops

Participants are informed in advance that the workshop involves hands-on exercises, including optional preparatory ones. Most enjoy the exercises and group discussions, which keep the sessions lively. Participants typically spend between two hours and two days in the workshop.

Policymakers

Policymakers join for a single 1–2-hour session. In in-person workshops, they are also invited to lunch – a valuable opportunity to connect with the researchers and research managers.

 

Do you want to know more about the policy engagement toolkit?

Do you want to share your experience in policy engagement? Do you think about contributing to the policy engagement toolkit? Feel free to contact Tome Sandevski via science-policy@pvw.uni-frankfurt.de

 

Student Internships

What is the format about?

Student internships are a well-established form of collaboration between universities and policymaking institutions. They are particularly suitable for students in the later years of a bachelor’s or master’s degree program. During an internship, students gain valuable professional experience and develop an understanding of how institutions operate from the inside. They become familiar with organizational structures, decision-making processes, strategic priorities, and day-to-day activities. Internships also provide opportunities to build professional networks that can support their future career development. For host institutions, internships offer the opportunity to benefit from students’ expertise, up-to-date academic knowledge, and fresh perspectives on the policy issues they address. The successful implementation of internships requires active engagement and sustained organizational support from both the university and the host institution. As such, this collaboration format contributes to the institutionalization of science-policy dialogue, the expansion of professional networks beyond the research community, and the establishment of long-term support mechanisms that become embedded in the functioning of both universities and policymaking institutions.

 

How it works

The duration of the internship, its content, and the formal requirements are determined through an agreement between the university and the host institution. In some study programs, internships are a compulsory part of the curriculum, while in others they are offered as an elective component that may replace part of the coursework or provide students with additional practical experience. In both cases, universities should actively encourage students to undertake internships within public sector institutions. An important role of the staff responsible for organizing and coordinating internships is to identify suitable students and match them with the appropriate department or unit within the host institution. The aim is to ensure that students’ knowledge and skills align with the needs of the workplace while providing them with relevant practical experience. One possible approach to selecting suitable candidates is for the host institution to define the desired applicant profile, after which students can be matched based on their motivation letter and the qualifications they have acquired during their studies.

Before the internship begins, several practical arrangements need to be completed. These include obtaining approval from the relevant university department, arranging the recognition of the internship for ECTS credits where applicable, concluding an agreement between the student and the host institution, and appointing one or more supervisors responsible for guiding the student throughout the internship. In addition to describing the internship tasks, the agreement may also specify working hours and the work location, the student’s level of involvement in the activities of the host institution, access rights to information, internal systems and tools, and the provision of any equipment required to perform the assigned tasks.

During the internship, the student becomes involved in the day-to-day activities of the host institution and contributes to tasks that reflect both the knowledge and skills acquired through their studies and the current needs of the host organization. At the beginning of the internship, it is therefore important to align expectations by clarifying what the student already knows, what they are expected to learn during the internship, and what the host institution expects from them. Students typically begin with basic tasks that help assess their abilities while also providing a learning opportunity. As they gain experience, they can gradually take on more complex tasks and make a more substantial contribution to the work of the host institution. The internship may also include the delivery of a specific output or project.

Once the internship has been completed, it should be evaluated. The evaluation may take different forms (e.g., an assessment, feedback form, or a report), but it should always focus on what the student has learned and how they have contributed to the host institution. The written evaluation is then submitted to the student’s academic department as confirmation of the completed internship and, where applicable, for the recognition of ECTS credits.

 

Challenges and how to solve them

  • The format, content, and expected outcomes of an internship need to be adapted to its duration; a one-week internship focused primarily on familiarization with the functioning of the institution will have a different structure than an internship lasting several months, which allows the student to become gradually involved in professional activities and to take on a greater level of responsibility
  • Students may have extensive theoretical knowledge but no experience applying it in practice; clear ssignments, regular feedback, and well-defined expected outcomes help prevent misunderstandings
  • In the case of students without previous work experience, sufficient attention needs to be paid to their adaptation to the work environment, including the clear definition of rules, expectations, and formal and informal workplace practices
  • The implementation of an internship places increased time demands on the supervisor and other staff involved in guiding the student; it is therefore appropriate to take this time investment into account already when planning the internship and to adapt the scope of tasks and the capacity of the host institution accordingly
  • At some universities and institutions, internships are organized more on an operational basis, depending on the needs and possibilities of individual university departments/host institution units, or through the human resources department, which occasionally mediates internship opportunities. This may result in a limited offer of internships and organizational shortcomings related to their coordination. A suitable solution is to establish a unified internship system at the level of the entire institution, which clearly defines a contact point for internship coordination, procedures for assigning internships and communication with universities/host institutions, while also allowing individual units to define their needs and capacities. This makes it possible to better connect students with relevant host departments.

 

Tasks and resources

The student

The students are required to familiarize themselves with the conditions and content of the internships and to agree with the host institution and the university on the formal requirements of the internship (e.g., administrative requirements, ECTS credits recognition, internship schedule and scope). During the internship, the student actively participates in the activities of the host department and completes assigned tasks within the agreed scope and deadlines. The student applies the knowledge and skills acquired through their studies when addressing tasks while also learning new procedures and methods of work in practice. They communicate with their supervisor, regularly verify their understanding of assigned tasks, and make use of the feedback provided. The student respects the rules and operations of the host institution, including work procedures, internal regulations, and any requirements regarding the confidentiality of information. Upon completion of the internship, the student fulfills the requirements set by the university and the host institution for the recognition and successful completion of the internship.

The supervisor

The supervisor provides professional guidance and support to the student throughout the internship. They assign tasks that correspond to the student’s knowledge and abilities, taking into account the current stage of the internship, with the aim of gradually increasing the student’s level of independence. The supervisor regularly monitors the completion of assigned tasks, provides feedback to the student, helps them understand the broader context of their work, and supports their involvement in the functioning of the workplace.

The coordination staff

The relevant staff member on the university side (HR officer, department secretary/assistant, or other support staff) is responsible for publishing the internship offer, selecting a suitable candidate, and connecting them with the relevant department or unit of the host institution. They provide the student with all necessary information regarding the organization and conditions of the internship and, where appropriate, facilitate communication with the department management, the student affairs office, etc. The relevant staff member on the host institution’s side serves as the student’s contact person both before the start of the internship and throughout its implementation. They ensure communication with the management of the relevant workplace and the selected supervisor, oversee the finalization of the internship conditions, and arrange the necessary documentation (agreement, evaluation form, etc.).

 

An example

Internship of a bachelor’s student in the Social Science Analyst program at the Control Department – Support and Data Processing Unit of the Regional Authority of the Olomouc Region.

Scope and organization of the internship

The internship was carried out over a total of 350 hours distributed across two semesters. The student was present at the workplace three days a week. She had her own workspace in the office and access to the necessary technical equipment, including a computer. Two supervisors were involved in supervising the internship; the student shared a workspace with them, and they provided her with ongoing support and guidance. An internship agreement was concluded with the student, and, upon completion of the internship, she received a certificate confirming completion of the placement as well as a written evaluation of the internship.

Professional focus of the internshipThe student’s focus was on qualitative data analysis, the interpretation of human behavior, and social science perspectives. This differed from the usual agenda of the workplace, which primarily works with structured data and its quantitative processing. While the workplace typically analyzes numerical data, the student contributed a perspective focused on understanding the broader contexts and factors underlying these data. Her professional focus therefore complemented the technically oriented approach of the workplace with insights from the social sciences.

 

Internship content and tasks

During the first half of the internship, the student focused on basic data preparation and data cleaning. Specifically, her tasks included:

  • Processing and categorizing a dataset on cultural and creative industries in the region
  • Processing the list of regional investments with regard to the geographical location of investments for future map visualization
  • Graphical presentation of data: editing interactive charts and tables, standardizing terminology, and ensuring the consistency of exported data
  • Working with metadata for datasets on the data portal; using AI to create dataset descriptions and tables for open datasets published on the data portal

During the second half of the internship, the student worked on more advanced tasks, including:

  • Statistical evaluation of data on cultural and creative industries in the region (e.g., in relation to the demographics of municipalities, education, employment, etc.)
  • Familiarization with spatial analyses and data visualization using maps in ArcGIS software
  • Identification of potential new datasets suitable for publication as open data and preparation of the results in the form of a presentation for the public open data portal

 

Benefits of the collaboration

The collaboration was beneficial for both parties. Thanks to her academic focus and subject-specific knowledge, the student brought a different approach to working with data, particularly qualitative analysis with an overlap into the field of psychometrics while also significantly reducing the workload of the department by assisting with routine tasks. During the internship, the student expanded her knowledge of quantitative data processing, which represents a more technical aspect of working with data. She learned to work with various data formats, to transform them into a standardized form, to ensure consistency in data processing, and to use freely available software tools for data visualization. At the same time, the internship represented the student’s first work experience and her first experience with the functioning of a public administration institution.

 

Do you want to know more about the policy engagement toolkit?

Do you want to share your experience in policy engagement? Do you think about contributing to the policy engagement toolkit? Feel free to contact Tome Sandevski via science-policy@pvw.uni-frankfurt.de

 

Marine and Environmental Researchers Learn to Pitch: A Case Study from DAM and Helmholtz Forum Earth and Environment

Key features in a nutshell

  • In 2025, the German Marine Research Alliance (DAM) and the Helmholtz Forum Earth and Environment organized two competence-building workshops on science–policy dialogue; about 40 of the approximately 50 participants went on to prepare and present four-minute policy pitches four to six weeks after the initial workshops
  • After each pitch, participants received structured feedback from their peers and the workshop facilitators; mst participants kept to the time limit and delivered well-structured presentations; the most common challenges were explaining the relevance of their research to policymakers, avoiding technical jargon, and especially formulating concrete policy options
  • The exercise proved to be an effective way to translate workshop content into practical skills and to prepare participants for future engagement with policymakers

 

How does the format work?

In January and June 2025, the German Marine Research Alliance (DAM) and the Helmholtz Forum Earth and Environment organized two competence-building workshops on science–policy dialogue in Berlin. Around 60 researchers and knowledge exchange officers from various research institutions participated across both workshops. Each workshop ran from noon to noon over two days and covered topics, including the roles of policymakers, understanding policymaking contexts, and an overview of policy engagement formats.

To make the workshop content applicable in practice, the facilitators invited participants to prepare a policy pitch as a follow-up exercise. The process unfolded in four steps.

Step 1: Introduce the exercise
In the final 30 minutes of each workshop, the facilitators explained the aims and structure of the follow-up exercise. Participation was optional. Participants who chose to take part were invited to present a four-minute policy pitch four to six weeks after the workshop. Several virtual dates were offered, and participants could select the one that suited them best. The exercise instructions were also sent to all participants in writing after the workshop.

Step 2: Participants prepare their pitches
Between the workshop and the follow-up session, participants prepared their policy pitches independently. Facilitators were available for questions by email, though none of the participants made use of this offer.

Step 3: Conduct the virtual pitch sessions
The virtual follow-up sessions lasted between 90 and 120 minutes. Each participant presented a policy pitch of no more than four minutes, followed by peer feedback and input from the facilitators. The peer-to-peer feedback proved particularly constructive, participants’ observations were thoughtful and constructive.

Step 4: Summarize and share the feedback
After the sessions, the facilitators compiled the key feedback points and shared them with all participants. This summary formed the basis for the written guidelines on preparing policy pitches and policy briefs, which were subsequently published on the DAM website.

 

What the exercise revealed: results and common challenges

Of the 50 workshop participants, 42 went on to present a policy pitch in the follow-up sessions – an outstanding participation rate of 84 percent for an optional exercise.

What worked well:

  • Most presentations were well structured and within the four-minute time limit
  • Peer-to-peer feedback was consistently constructive and generated substantive discussion
  • Participants reported that the exercise helped them apply what they had learned in the workshop to their own research

Common challenges:

  • Technical jargon: Several participants used terms familiar within their field without realizing these would be unfamiliar to a policy audience
  • Relevance framing: Explaining why their research matters to policymakers – rather than to fellow researchers – proved difficult for a number of participants
  • Policy options: Formulating concrete, actionable policy options based on research findings was the most consistently challenging element of the exercise.

 

Tasks and resources: Brief description of the tasks and resources needed by scientists, knowledge exchange officers/research managers and policymakers

Workshop facilitators

Facilitators introduce the exercise during the final session of the workshop, set the virtual follow-up dates, send written instructions to participants, moderate the pitch and feedback sessions, and compile and distribute a summary of the key feedback points afterwards.

Researchers and research managers (workshop participants)

Participants prepare a four-minute policy pitch on their own research topic between the workshop and the follow-up session, present it in the virtual session, and provide peer feedback on their fellow participants’ pitches.

Policymakers

Policymakers did not participate in the pitch sessions in the 2025 editions of this exercise. However, they did participate in the initial workshops, where they emphasized the importance of concise, accessible, and policy-relevant presentations. Future editions of the exercise could benefit from including at least one policymaker in the feedback sessions.

Do you want to know more about the policy engagement toolkit?

Do you want to share your experience in policy engagement? Do you think about contributing to the policy engagement toolkit? Feel free to contact Tome Sandevski via science-policy@pvw.uni-frankfurt.de

Conversations that Open Doors

A World Café on Policy Careers and How Policymaking Institutions Work. A Case Study from Goethe-University Frankfurt


Key features in a nutshell

  • This event format brings early-career researchers into direct conversation with practitioners from regional and national ministries and government agencies, the European Commission, NGOs, and media in a relaxed, small-group setting
  • Using the World Café method, participants rotate between tables across three discussion rounds, allowing them to engage with multiple practitioners and perspectives in a single session
  • Early-career researchers gain firsthand insight into how ministries and other policy institutions actually work – knowledge that cannot be obtained from reading official documents alone
  • The format addresses a structural gap in many academic careers: researchers rarely have the opportunity to ask practitioners directly about career pathways, entry requirements, and the realities of working at the science-policy interface

How does the format work?

This event format was developed and is co-organized by the Policy Engagement Unit at Goethe University Frankfurt – through the Mercator Science-Policy Fellowship Programme and the Erasmus+ project ENGAGEgreen — and the Goethe Research Academy for Early Career Researchers (GRADE). The combination of science-policy expertise and graduate school infrastructure makes it particularly effective, as it addresses two knowledge gaps simultaneously.

First, early-career researchers often do not know how to make their research expertise available to professionals in ministries, the European Commission, NGOs, or media – and they rarely understand what those institutions actually need in terms of scientific input. Second, early-career researchers face a fundamental career decision: whether to pursue a path in academia or beyond. Direct conversations with practitioners provide them with a realistic picture of what non-academic careers at the science-policy interface actually look like.

Since its launch in 2019, the format has been continuously refined. To date, more than 60 policymakers and practitioners and 250 early-career researchers from Goethe University Frankfurt, TU Darmstadt, and Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz have participated.

The event can be organized in five steps.

Step 1: Write the event description

A clear event description helps attract the right participants – both early-career researchers and practitioners. The description should explain the purpose of the event, the key discussion questions, and the methods used. It serves as the basis for announcements in course catalogues, newsletters, and websites.

A sample event description:

Constructive dialogue among science, policy, media, and civil society requires more than good communication from researchers. Policy institutions, NGOs, and the media also need staff who can understand scientific findings and bring them to bear on societal decision making. This event explores how researchers can successfully make the transition from academia to ministries and other policy organizations, the European Commission, international organizations, NGOs, and media — and what challenges await them along the way.

We discuss the following questions with policymaking professionals and representatives from media and NGOs:

  • In what contexts do you draw on scientific expertise, and how do you access and use research findings?
  • What career pathways exist in your organization, and what are the entry prospects for doctoral researchers?
  • What competencies and experiences are most important for making the transition from academia?
  • How does working in a policy institution, NGO, or media organization differ from academia – with respect to pace, decision making, and ways of working – and why?

Methods: brief inputs by practitioners from various organizations; Q&A with the audience; small-group discussions; informal lunch with practitioners.

Step 2: Plan and organize the event

Fix the date and book the room five to seven months in advance. The room should comfortably accommodate 30 to 60 people. Use a banquet layout: round or rectangular tables with five to eight chairs each. Depending on the number of practitioners invited, you will need between five to twelve tables.

Once the event description is finalized, include it in the course catalogue of your graduate school or early-career researcher support structure so that participants can register in advance. A waiting list system is useful for popular editions of the event.

Step 3: Recruit practitioners and table facilitators

Reach out to policymakers and representatives from NGOs and media by contacting practitioners who are fellows or alumni of science-policy programs at your institution or partner universities. Human resources offices at ministries and public agencies can also be useful points of contact. Provide the event description and invite practitioners to join as experts. Aim to recruit between six to ten practitioners per event — enough to offer participants a meaningful choice of tables and perspectives across three rounds.

At the same time, recruit colleagues to serve as table facilitators. Their role is to keep discussions on track, ensure all participants have a chance to speak, and note down the questions raised by early-career researchers for later evaluation.

Step 4: Run the event

Practitioners typically arrive 15 to 30 minutes before the start of the event. Each practitioner is assigned to a table for the duration of the event. A typical program is as follows:

A typical event outline looks like this:

09:30-10:00: Arrival, registration, and informal get-together

10:00-10:10: Introduction: hosting organizations and event format. In our case: Introduction of the ENGAGEgreen project, the Mercator Science-Policy Fellowship-Programme and the Goethe Research Academy for Early Career Researchers.

10:10-10:40: Each practitioner introduces themselves. Guiding questions for the introduction: What are the tasks of your organization? What are your individual tasks? When do you need scientific evidence? Via which channels do you gain access to scientific evidence (e.g., policy briefs, commissioned research reports, expert talks, policy events)? What are typical career paths in your organization?

10:40-11:20: The early-career researchers move to the tables. First discussion round (Q&A session at the tables). Early-career researchers and table facilitators move to a new table after each round. Practitioners remain at their tables throughout. This allows each practitioner to speak with three different groups over the course of the event, and each participant to meet at least three different practitioners.

11:20-11:30: Coffee break

11:30-12:20: The early-career researchers move to the next table of their choice. The practitioners remain at their tables. Second small-group discussion round.

12:20-12:30: Coffee break

12:30-13:10: The early-career researchers move to the next table of their choice. The practitioners remain at their tables. Third small-group discussion round.

13:10-13:20: Invite two or three practitioners and two or three early-career researchers to share their reflections in plenary: What was the most interesting thing you learned today? What surprised you most? Close by sharing a QR code linking to the electronic feedback form. Distributing the QR code at this moment – when participants are still in the room – consistently yields response rates of 70 percent or higher.

13:20-14:20: Light lunch and networking

Step 5: Evaluate and follow up

Process the participant feedback promptly and use it to adjust the format for future editions. Send thank-you notes to all practitioners within a few days of the event. Where participants have noted recurring questions or knowledge gaps, consider compiling these into a practical Q&A handout for future participants.

 

Tasks and resources: Brief description of the tasks and resources needed by scientists, knowledge exchange officers/research managers, and policymakers

Workshop facilitators

Organizers are responsible for the full event cycle: writing the event description and announcing it via the relevant course catalogue or newsletter; booking the room, arranging seating, microphones, and catering; recruiting practitioners and table facilitators; and processing feedback after the event. The preparation phase typically spans several weeks.

Scientists

Early-career researchers should set aside approximately 3.5 to 4.5 hours for the event, including the informal lunch. Organizers may wish to share the key discussion questions in advance so that participants can prepare their own questions for practitioners.

Policymakers

Practitioners should set aside approximately 3.5 to 4.5 hours, including the informal lunch. Some practitioners bring career information materials to share with participants; this is encouraged and adds practical value to the conversations.

Sources and further reading

Do you want to know more about the policy engagement toolkit?

Do you want to share your experience in policy engagement? Do you think about contributing to the policy engagement toolkit? Feel free to contact Tome Sandevski via science-policy@pvw.uni-frankfurt.de

 

Put Yourself in my Shoes: Role-Playing for a Better Policy Design

Summary: Key features in a nutshell

  • Originated from an academic participant’s observation of a local problem (difficulties in dialogue between providers of public interest services)
  • Mobilized the quadruple helix model (academia, policymakers, private sector, civil society) plus Master’s students
  • Resulted in two webinars discussing key issues and an experiential workshop led by academic scholars (full professor and researchers) and knowledge exchange managers
  • The experimental workshop included group works in a role-playing mode, in order for participants to understand how other professional job role works
  • Final debate and networking
  • Ultimately, it allows for a new perspective and a broader understanding of the policymaking and implementation process

 

Description

This case study points out how a common language can be constructed with respect  to policy design or policy implementation in the region, thanks to an experiment launched by the Department of Economics at Ca’ Foscari University of Venice and Ca’ Foscari Challenge School (the executive school of Ca’ Foscari University of Venice offering Master’s degrees and advanced training courses for professionals) under the Erasmus+ ENGAGEgreen project.

The program was organized into three constituent parts: two online meetings an in-person experiential workshop. This approach facilitates the engagement of researchers, policymakers, students, and workers/representatives from the third sector, NGOs, and civil society.

 

The starting point

The impetus for establishing a workshop that facilitates collaboration among diverse professionals engaged in public policy emerged from the observations of a researcher from the Department of Economics at Ca’ Foscari University of Venice. The researcher was involved in a field research project in the planning office of a public body that collaborates with third sector organizations to provide services and relies on university research centers for the methodological definition of planning tools. Through field observation, it became clear that there was a problem in the dialogue between different bodies on the same issues, with regard to both administrative and methodological processes – in this specific case, the coproduction of social services.

 

Who should be involved as participants?

Master’s students, doctoral students, researchers, professors, mayors, councilors, public sector workers, third sector workers, and civil society.

 

How does the format work?

The initiative begins with the collection of participants’ registration. This step may seem obvious, but it is equally essential for creating a mixed classroom composed of different professionals and roles.

 

Subsequently, two online webinars are planned, led by professionals and university professors. The number of introductory webinars may vary based on the need for further study and the topics to be covered. The webinars aim to bring together the key topics of the course from both a theoretical perspective (looking at both the legal/administrative and methodological/sociological aspects) and a practical perspective. Ideally, the introductory webinars should lay the foundations for what will then be shared and implemented during the experiential workshop. The ideal structure should include at least one webinar held by academics to share theoretical foundations and at least one webinar held by public sector professionals to share the operating methods implemented by public offices.

 

The last and most important meeting is an experiential workshop divided into two parts:

  • In the first part, the key theme of the day is explored in depth through a presentation by an academic expert on the subject, who will then support the working groups to resolve any theoreticalissues;
  • The second part – which should last at least three hours – is the core of the activity and involves dividing the participants into mixed groups. It will proceed as follows:
    • the group work will take the form of a role-playing game, replicating a real-life operational situation involving discussions between various organizations and professionals, as would happen in reality;
    • as in any role-playing game, participants will put themselves in someone else’s shoes so the mayor may be a third sector worker, the public sector worker may be the councilor, the third sector worker may be the researcher, etc.
    • tasks are assigned – for example, the preparation of a collaboration agreement between institutions, and participants must draft the document, remembering that, on this occasion, they must represent an institution or role other than their own;
    • each group will have a knowledge exchange manager who will help participants stay on track.

 

Participants:

5 researchers

37 policymakers

6 students

5 NGO/civil society representatives

30 other (business/private)

 

Challenges

  • involve different professionals and roles from different organizations and territories
  • ensure that participants have a uniform level of knowledge
  • make it clear that during the experiential workshop group work, participants are representing another organization and/or another role and therefore need to think differently

 

Task and resources

Academics

The program is very time efficient for academics. Since the meetings are about topics they already cover in conferences or courses, they do not have to invest much time in preparing other than reading about the topics of interest.

Support staff (researchers, knowledge exchange managers, and research managers)

The department employed

  • two researchers, already part of the staff, to handle the methodological management of the initiative
  • two research managers who handled the organizational aspects
  • three knowledge exchange managers who facilitated the group work

Policymakers/researchers/workers from public bodies and the third sector

The participants must submit an application that takes them a couple of minutes to prepare.

Required funding

Light networking lunch was offered at the end of the workshop.

 

Sources and further reading

Event poster.

Other